mathjax

Showing posts with label Hawthorne Effect. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Hawthorne Effect. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Again, MAKE POLICE WEAR CAMERAS



A policeman that know he's being watched can be saved from his own bad behavior. It's called the Hawthorne effect, and it improved behavior 75 years ago. It's a scientifically demonstrated, although disputed, effect on human behavior.

http://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.2316555.1428463384!/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_300/image.jpg



Here is the reality, the policeman will know he is not being observed all the time, but if there is an incident that warrants review the imagery from a camera will be reviewed.  If the imagery conflicts with the story he explains to his superiors he knows he will be caught.  Knowing that any inconsistency may be found out, what is the reason one would have to make up a story about an incident? If one knows they cannot lie their way out of a situation, then they know that they will be found out.

If they can't get away with the crime, then the cost-benefit analysis of any grey area situation is slanted to not acting badly.

If you want to read what the Hawthorne effect has done in other areas of crime prevention:

http://www.popcenter.org/library/CrimePrevention/Volume_13/Anticipatory_Benefits_in_Crime_Prevention.pdf


Thursday, December 4, 2014

Body Camera Rule: How do you stop a policeman from turning off a camera?

  
 

My suggestion for the laws around body camera use is that body cameras should be enforced by law.  If the officer turns off his camera, then his testimony is discounted versus other witnesses.  That should be the law; turn off the camera, then you are treated as suspect. 

Body cameras should also have a log of when the device is turned off, turned on, and complete GPS location for the entire shift.  The more data the better.

Monday, November 24, 2014

Equip all police officers with cameras





People act differently when a camera is on them or on their actions.  It's called the Hawthorne Effect. People modify their behavior under inspection. It makes them, in general, act better.

This has now been shown to reduce incidents of violence; http://phys.org/news/2014-12-scientific-police-body-worn-cameras-unacceptable-use-of-force.html

Let's reduce the confusion and reduce the leeway police have to act inappropriately by making them wear a camera during their shift.  It helps for evidence.  Anyone who attacks a police officer knows it. The evidence cuts both ways - it can justify good behavior and incriminate bad behavior.  That is fair to all. It won't eliminate confusion but it will shed more light on what went on.

How much have the Ferguson riots damaged the economy?  How much would the cameras be?